⚡ EV Life Club

Calculated by a club member

Kia e-Niro 2021 vs Tesla Model Y 2023: cost of owning over 2 years

🇱🇻 Latvija · 25,000 km a year · 2 years · calculated 2026-10-27

Kia e-Niro 2021 costs €3,549 less over 2 years.
CarTotalPer monthPer kmBought forWorth at the end
Kia e-Niro 2021
used, 110,000 km
€10,494€437€0.21€20,000€15,253
Tesla Model Y 2023
used, 115,000 km
€14,043€585€0.28€32,000€24,781

What the money goes on

Kia e-Niro 2021Tesla Model Y 2023
Depreciation€4,747€7,219
Energy€1,862€2,257
Servicing€2,006€1,593
Repairs€226€883
Major failures€23€120
Battery risk€12€0
Tyres€727€957
Insurance€848€970
One-offs€44€45
Total€10,494€14,043

What the club's analyst says

For this buyer, keeping the current Kia e-Niro is the better option, provided diagnostics find no issues with the drivetrain or battery. Switching to a Model Y to reduce costs over two years is not justified: the time saved on fast charging is small, while depreciation and running costs are higher.

The main advantages of keeping the Kia are lower depreciation on a car already owned, lower energy consumption, and cheaper tires. The Tesla charges faster on the road and retains battery warranty coverage for the planned mileage, but the owner already pays for routine repairs. For the Kia, exceeding the warranty mileage limit near the end of the period is important. With 90% home charging, total charging time is about 17.4 hours for the Tesla versus 22.9 hours for the Kia over two years: the gain of about 5.5 hours does not change the financial conclusion.

What decides it

Calculate with your own numbersThe full reportDiscuss in the club's channel

How it is calculated

The price, what the car is still worth at the end, energy at the country's prices, servicing, repairs and the risk of big failures, tyres, insurance and taxes — for the mileage and years above. The AI looks up the cars' data; the sums are made by the calculator itself, the same way for every car. Prices are those of the day of the calculation.

More comparisons