⚡ EV Life Club

Duel of the day

MINI Cooper 2023 vs Renault 5 E-Tech 2026: cost of owning over 5 years

🇦🇹 Österreich · 15,000 km a year · 5 years · calculated 2026-11-18

MINI Cooper 2023 costs €6,516 less over 5 years.
CarTotalPer monthPer kmBought forWorth at the end
MINI Cooper 2023
used, 30,000 km
€30,844€514€0.41€24,000€12,528
Renault 5 E-Tech 2026
new
€37,360€623€0.50€32,690€15,640

What the money goes on

MINI Cooper 2023Renault 5 E-Tech 2026
Depreciation€11,472€17,050
Energy€5,347€5,148
Servicing€1,132€346
Repairs€1,386€411
Major failures€47€15
Battery risk€6€0
Tyres€846€911
Insurance€10,408€10,928
Taxes€0€2,300
One-offs€200€250
Total€30,844€37,360

What the club's analyst says

For the specified mileage, the MINI looks like the better-value purchase, if its real-world range and four seats are sufficient. Before buying, battery diagnostics and checking the remaining warranty are especially important.

The MINI has a lower expected depreciation and lower listed taxes, although maintenance and repair costs are higher. The Renault is more convenient for trips: the estimated owner time over five years is about 58 hours versus 91 hours for the MINI, mainly because of more frequent fast charging. Both have an NMC battery: using the 20–80% range for everyday driving gives access to about 60% of the rated range; charging to 100% is best reserved for long trips.

The more expensive Renault offers greater range, a fifth seat and a larger trunk, but the MINI is quicker when overtaking. Heated seats, a premium audio system and adaptive cruise control are included in the Renault’s equipment, but were options on the MINI; their cost is not specified for comparison.

What decides it

MINI Cooper 2023

Pluses

  • The more powerful motor provides quicker overtaking.
  • Slightly quicker acceleration from a standstill.
  • A head-up display was available as an option; check whether the car has one.
  • A panoramic roof was available as an option; check whether the car has one.

Minuses

  • Shorter range means more frequent charging stops.
  • Four seats and a smaller trunk limit practicality.
  • Peak fast-charging power is lower.

Renault 5 E-Tech 2026

Pluses

  • Greater range is more convenient on long trips.
  • Five seats and a larger trunk are more practical for family and luggage.
  • Heated seats and adaptive cruise control are included in the equipment.
  • Higher peak fast-charging power reduces reliance on long stops.

Minuses

  • Slower to overtake than the MINI.
  • A head-up display and panoramic roof are not offered.
  • OTA updates arrive irregularly; some fixes require a dealer visit.

Calculate with your own numbersThe full reportDiscuss in the club's channel

How it is calculated

The price, what the car is still worth at the end, energy at the country's prices, servicing, repairs and the risk of big failures, tyres, insurance and taxes — for the mileage and years above. The AI looks up the cars' data; the sums are made by the calculator itself, the same way for every car. Prices are those of the day of the calculation.

More comparisons